Short Sales: When You Owe More Than the House Is Worth

A short sale is a sale of a house for less than the total owed on the loans secured by it, made with the lender's approval, so the lender accepts the sale proceeds and releases its lien. The decision belongs to the lender, not to the seller, the agent or any buyer. In California, Code of Civil Procedure section 580e bars a deficiency on a one-to-four unit dwelling when the lender gives written consent and the conditions are met, but the forgiven amount can still raise a federal tax question. Before you choose one, talk to your lender, a HUD-approved housing counselor, an attorney and a tax professional.

This article is part of our series on behind on payments, liens and tax defaults. For every option, starting with the ones that keep the house, read behind on payments in California: your options, the timeline and the two numbers.

What is a short sale?

The California Department of Real Estate's consumer alert on residential short sales defines it simply: a sale in which the outstanding debt secured by the property was more than the price the property sold for. The sale comes up "short" of what is owed, the lender is paid back less than it lent, and the alert notes that "a sale of this type requires bank/lender approval."

Short sales come up in two kinds of files. Some owners are current on the loan but owe more than the house would bring. Others are behind on payments, with a notice of default recorded and a sale date approaching, which adds a deadline to everything below. If that is you, read what pre-foreclosure means and where you stand before the sale date as well.

Are you actually short? The arithmetic

Being short is not a feeling; it is a subtraction. Fill this in with your own payoff statements and a realistic price. Every figure here is a dash, because yours comes from your loans and your house.

LineAmount

Likely sale price

-

Less: first loan payoff, including any arrears and fees

-

Less: second loan or home equity line payoff

-

Less: property tax, special tax and association arrears

-

Less: other recorded liens

-

Less: selling and closing costs

-

Net, or shortfall if negative

-

The "likely sale price" line is where people go wrong, in both directions. An automated estimate from a website is a statistical estimate that has not seen the house. A CMA is an agent's opinion of likely sale price from comps. A certified appraisal is an independent opinion of value by a licensed appraiser. A cash purchase offer is a price someone will actually pay, on stated terms. The lender in a short sale relies on its own valuation, and the DRE alert warns that false broker price opinions or appraisals have been used to push values down so an insider can buy cheaply and resell.

If the bottom line is positive after every lien and cost, you are not short, and a short sale is the wrong tool. If it is negative, no ordinary sale can pay everyone, and the lender's consent becomes the whole question.

Who decides, and what California's deficiency rule says

Each lender with a lien on the house has to agree to take less. Code of Civil Procedure section 580e says that when the holder of a deed of trust on a dwelling of not more than four units gives written consent to a sale for less than the amount owed, no deficiency may be owed or collected on that note, provided title is transferred by a recorded deed and the sale proceeds are tendered to the lender as agreed. Three more parts of the section matter:

• A lender may not require the seller to pay additional compensation, beyond the sale proceeds, in exchange for its written consent.
• The protection does not apply if the borrower is a corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership or political subdivision.
• It does not limit a lender's remedies for fraud or waste by the borrower.

The DRE alert, written before the current version of section 580e, warns that a seller may be sued for the forgiven amount and that second or third lienholders may pursue a deficiency even when the first lender forgives. Whether section 580e protects you with every lienholder on your house is a question for an attorney, with the consent letters in hand.

The tax question on the forgiven amount

The IRS says that canceled debt is generally taxable, and that the creditor may send you a Form 1099-C, Cancellation of Debt. Its topic page lists exclusions, including debt canceled while you are insolvent and qualified principal residence indebtedness discharged before January 1, 2026, or under a written arrangement entered into before that date. Which exclusion, if any, fits your sale, and how California treats it, is a question for a tax professional before you sign. The DRE alert gives the same advice: get an accountant and a lawyer as well as a licensed agent.

Short sale or another path?

PathWho approvesDeficiency questionTax questionNet to you

Reinstatement or modification

Your lender

None while the loan continues

Ask your tax professional

Keep the house

Short sale

Every lienholder taking less

Section 580e, with written consent

Possible canceled debt

-

Listing with equity

You

None if every lien is paid

Ordinary sale

-

As-is cash sale with equity

You

None if every lien is paid

Ordinary sale

-

Trustee sale

Nobody; it happens on the date

Ask an attorney

Ask a tax professional

-

When listing wins. If the arithmetic shows equity after every lien, and there is time before any sale date, listing on the open market will usually net more than a cash buyer. Our written recommendation says so, and introduces you to a designated local expert, an independently licensed agent. Mr. Cali Offers never lists a house. See when we tell a seller to list instead.

Where a buyer fits in a short sale, and the red flags

A buyer, cash or financed, can be the purchaser in a lender-approved short sale, but the price and the closing are subject to the lender's written approval, and no buyer can promise that approval. The DRE alert lists red flags to watch for:

• A short sale negotiator who is not a licensed real estate broker, or a salesperson working under one. The alert says only real estate licensees, California lawyers acting as lawyers and investors acting on their own behalf can negotiate short sales.
• An advance fee for short sale work without a DRE no-objection letter for the fee contract.
• Any payment made "outside" of escrow instead of disclosed in the escrow documents.
• A value given to the lender that is lower than what the market will bear.

That last point is why we put two numbers on the same house: an as-is cash offer and an open-market read, each with the comps, the deductions and the net after your payoffs. The open-market read is a preliminary estimate, not an appraisal. If the sheet shows you are short, it says so plainly, and the conversation turns to your lender, your agent and your attorney.

What this looks like in practice

These are the kinds of files that come in, described without names or figures. A Chino Hills owner in a planned community, with a first loan, a home equity line and association dues in arrears, who needed to know whether the house was short before calling either lender. An owner who had received a notice of default and assumed a short sale was the only option, until the subtraction showed equity after all.

If you want the arithmetic done on your house, see how we map both numbers against your payoff and dates, or call (909) 498-3977. There is no cost and no obligation to get the two numbers and the written report.

Sources

• California Department of Real Estate, Consumer Alert: Warning Regarding Residential "Short" Sales: dre.ca.gov, accessed October 31, 2026
• California Code of Civil Procedure section 580e (no deficiency after a lender-consented short sale): leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, accessed October 31, 2026
• Internal Revenue Service, Topic no. 431, Canceled debt: is it taxable or not?: irs.gov, accessed October 31, 2026
• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, How do I find a HUD-approved housing counselor?: consumerfinance.gov, accessed October 31, 2026
• Judicial Branch of California, Your rights in a nonjudicial foreclosure: selfhelp.courts.ca.gov, accessed October 31, 2026

Mr. Cali Offers is not a law firm, a lender, a tax adviser or a short sale negotiator. Cash offers come from independent buyers and investors who buy for their own account and may resell for profit; a cash offer is generally below what the open market would bring. Any value shown is a preliminary estimate, not an appraisal. Nothing here is legal, tax or financial advice.