A lender balks at an as-is house when its appraiser finds a deficiency that affects the property's safety, soundness or structural integrity. Under Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, that condition rating, C6, makes the loan ineligible for sale to Fannie Mae until the deficient items are repaired, so the appraisal is completed "subject to" the repairs. The as-is clause in your contract does not change what the buyer's lender requires; if nobody completes the repairs before closing, the financed buyer usually cannot close, and the buyer pool for that house narrows to cash buyers.
This guide explains the condition ratings a lender's appraiser assigns, which ones still allow a loan on an as-is house, what a "subject to" appraisal does to an escrow, and when repairing first and listing nets more than selling as-is for cash. Lending questions about a specific loan belong with the buyer's lender; this article describes the rules and does not apply them to your file.
Two different documents: your contract and the buyer's loan
An as-is clause is a promise between buyer and seller: the seller will not make repairs and the buyer takes the house in its present condition. The buyer's lender is not a party to that promise. The lender orders its own appraisal, a certified appraisal by a licensed or certified appraiser, and applies its own property rules before it funds. That is why an as-is listing can go into escrow with a financed buyer and then stall: the buyer agreed to the condition, but the loan did not.
This article quotes Fannie Mae's Selling Guide, section B4-1.3-06, because it states its property-condition rules in plain terms. Other loan programs and individual lenders apply their own standards, and only the buyer's lender can say which ones govern a given loan.
What the lender's appraiser rates
The appraiser gives the house a condition rating from C1 to C6 and a quality-of-construction rating from Q1 to Q6. Two condition ratings matter most for an as-is sale:
- C5. The guide describes it as improvements that "feature obvious deferred maintenance and are in need of some significant repairs."
- C6. Deficiencies "severe enough to affect the safety, soundness, or structural integrity of the improvements."
The rating is for the whole house, not one room: if any portion of the dwelling is rated C6, the whole dwelling must be rated C6. The same rule applies to the quality rating at Q6.
C5 still finances as-is; C6 is where the loan stops
This is the line most sellers do not know exists. The guide says properties rated C1 through C5 "are eligible in 'as is' condition." A tired house with obvious deferred maintenance and significant repairs ahead can still carry a conventional loan sold to Fannie Mae without anyone fixing it first.
A C6 house cannot. The guide states that loans secured by properties rated C6 are not eligible for sale to Fannie Mae, and that for a C6 property the appraisal must be completed "subject to" completion of the deficient items, with a resulting condition rating of at least C5. A Q6 house is eligible only if the items affecting safety, soundness or structural integrity are repaired before the loan is delivered.
Small items usually do not trigger this. The guide lists minor conditions and deferred maintenance, such as worn floor finishes or carpet, minor plumbing leaks, holes in window screens, missing handrails or cracked window glass, and says that while such conditions generally do not rise to the level of a required repair, they must be reported.
Appraiser's findingWhat it means for the financed buyerWhat it means for an as-is seller
Minor conditions reported
Generally not a required repair
Sale can proceed as-is
C5: deferred maintenance, significant repairs needed
Eligible in as-is condition
Sale can proceed as-is
C6: safety, soundness or structural integrity affected
Not eligible until repaired; appraisal "subject to"
Repairs before closing, or a buyer who does not need that loan
Appraiser not qualified to judge the item
Appraisal "subject to" a qualified professional's inspection
Another inspection, and possibly repairs, before closing
What "subject to" does to an escrow
When the appraisal comes back "subject to" repairs, the guide requires the appraiser to identify and describe the physical deficiencies, and the property must be appraised subject to completion of the specific repairs or alterations. If the appraiser is not qualified to evaluate an item, the appraisal is completed subject to a satisfactory inspection by a qualified professional. In an escrow, that usually leaves the seller with a choice to make quickly:
- Make the repair before closing. The seller still owns the house, so the work, any permit and the cost fall on the seller unless the contract is renegotiated. Ask the buyer's lender what evidence of completion it needs.
- Renegotiate. A price reduction or credit changes the money, but it does not by itself complete a repair the loan is conditioned on. Whether the lender will accept any arrangement is a question for that lender.
- Let the buyer change loan programs. Some buyers may qualify under a different program with different property rules. That is the buyer's lender's call, and it takes time.
- Cancel and sell to a buyer who does not need that loan. That is usually a cash buyer, and the price reflects it.
The cost of an escrow that fails late is its own subject; see financing fall-through risk and what it costs a seller. When the problem is the appraised value rather than the condition, the house appraised below the contract price, the mechanics are different; that case is in appraisal gaps: when a financed buyer's loan comes in short.
Disclosure does not change either way
A lender's condition finding does not replace the seller's disclosures, and an as-is clause does not remove them. Civil Code section 1102 applies California's transfer disclosure rules to sales of single-family residential property and says any waiver of them is void as against public policy. If an appraisal report or an inspection tells you something new about the house, ask your attorney or the escrow officer whether it now belongs on your disclosures. The Transfer Disclosure Statement for as-is sellers covers the form.
Why this narrows the buyer pool
Whether the house is in Los Angeles, San Bernardino or Riverside County, a house likely to rate C6 shuts out every buyer whose loan depends on a rule like Fannie Mae's: before they make an offer, if their agent recognizes the risk, or in escrow, if the appraiser does. What is left is buyers who can close without that loan, often investors buying for their own account. What that does to price and contract terms is covered in as-is listings that attract only investors, and the full picture of what an as-is buyer accepts is in the as-is pillar.
The housing era tells you where the risk sits. A pre-war house near the Village in Claremont or along Euclid Avenue in Upland is where wiring, plumbing and the foundation get the closest look. A post-war tract house with a converted garage in Pomona raises a different question, unpermitted space, which is often more about value than safety. A newer master-planned house in Ontario Ranch in Ontario is a different case again, where the community facilities district special tax usually matters more to the net than condition. None of those is a rating; only the appraiser assigns one.
When repairing first and listing nets more
Selling as-is for cash is not automatically the answer to a balky lender. Listing, or keeping the financed buyer, usually nets more when:
- the item that would push the house to C6 is specific and limited, and you can fund it, permit it and finish it before closing;
- the rest of the house would rate C5 or better, so financed buyers can buy it as-is once that item is done;
- the location and lot would draw several owner-occupant buyers competing for the house;
- you have the time a repair and a listing take.
In that case the written report says so, and you are introduced to a designated local expert, an independently licensed California agent who works your neighborhood. Mr. Cali Offers never lists a house. When the repair is large, uncertain or impossible to finish on your timeline, the cash column shows what the condition costs, line by line, so you can compare it with the repair-first route.
What this looks like in practice
These are the kinds of files that come in, described without names or figures.
- A seller whose financed buyer's appraisal came back "subject to" a structural repair, who wanted both numbers before deciding whether to fix it in escrow.
- An executor who listed an older house as-is, saw the first escrow stall on the lender's condition finding and wanted to know whether a cash sale or a repair nets the estate more.
- An owner who wanted to know before listing whether any item was likely to stop a loan, so the price and the buyer pool could be set to match.
Next step
If a lender has balked at your house, or you expect one to, get the two numbers on it as-is or call (909) 498-3977. The as-is sales hub has the rest of the series. There is no cost and no obligation to get the two numbers and the written report.
Sources
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-06, Property Condition and Quality of Construction of the Improvements: selling-guide.fanniemae.com (accessed November 6, 2026)
- California Civil Code section 1102 (transfers the disclosure article covers; waivers void as against public policy), copy read on california.public.law, accessed November 6, 2026
Mr. Cali Offers is not a lender, a law firm or an appraiser. Cash offers come from independent buyers and investors who buy for their own account and may resell for profit; a cash offer is generally below what the open market would bring. Any value shown is a preliminary estimate, not an appraisal. Nothing here is legal, tax or financial advice.
Frequently asked questions
Can a buyer get a mortgage on a house sold as-is?
Often, yes. Fannie Mae's Selling Guide says properties rated C1 through C5 are eligible in as-is condition, and C5 covers obvious deferred maintenance with significant repairs needed. The problem is a C6 rating, for deficiencies affecting safety, soundness or structural integrity, which must be repaired before the loan is eligible. Other loan programs set their own rules; the buyer's lender can say which apply.
What does an appraisal subject to repairs mean?
It means the appraiser found deficiencies that must be completed before the loan can proceed on that appraisal. Under Fannie Mae's guide, a C6 property must be appraised subject to completion of the deficient items, with a resulting rating of at least C5. If the appraiser is not qualified to judge an item, the appraisal is subject to an inspection by a qualified professional.
Does an as-is clause stop the lender from requiring repairs?
No. The as-is clause is an agreement between buyer and seller. The buyer's lender applies its own property rules before funding, so a required repair can stall the escrow even when the buyer accepted the condition. Questions about a specific loan go to that lender.
Should I repair the house or sell it as-is for cash after a lender balks?
Repairing first usually nets more when the item is specific, you can fund and finish it before closing, the rest of the house would rate C5 or better and several financed buyers would compete for it. When the repair is large or uncertain, an as-is cash offer with line-item deductions shows what the condition costs so the two routes can be compared.
Written by
Anthony Grynchal
Anthony Grynchal is a California real estate salesperson with eXp Realty, licensed since November 2009 (CA DRE #01873626), and the owner of Mr. Cali Offers.
More about AnthonyPublished
